It is probably a faux pas to post this recipe, since I only took two iPhone pictures of the process, but it was so good, you're going to have to forgive my lack of pictures and just make this soup. It is easy and healthy and delicious, and does not require precise measurements, which is nice. Heck, it doesn't even require adding the specific ingredients I added, there is a lot of room for spontaneity.
I originally made this soup last fall because I really wanted butternut squash soup, but when I went to the grocery to buy some, it was SO expensive for 2 servings. And I was having company over and needed at least 6 servings. This option is much less expensive. In the fall, butternut squash is usually around $1 a pound!
I started with about 5 pounds of butternut squash. In the past, this has meant one large squash, this time, I got two smaller ones. I wear gloves to peel the squash because my skin reacts negatively to the raw butternut squash flesh. It's pretty common, some people are allergic to touching the insides of the squash, and my hands get red and peely and pretty gross. If this happens to you, don't worry. It goes away after a couple hours. But if you want to be safe, just use normal kitchen rubber gloves. Clean ones. For peeling, I just use a normal vegetable peeler. It's kind of a work out, just so you're prepared.
After the squash is peeled, cut it into 1-inch(ish) cubes. You can set these aside for a little bit.
In a large pot (I used the largest one I had that wasn't a broth pot), melt 4 tablespoons of butter. I used salted, but we add salt later as well, so it doesn't really matter if you use salted or unsalted butter. Cut up either one large onion or two small onions (I used a brown onion, I think either white, sweet or brown would be fine. Maybe not a red onion, it could throw off the color of the soup at the end!) and throw into the melted butter. You can cut these roughly and the pieces can be fairly large. You will blend these later, so your onion chopping does not have to be perfect. These will cook in the butter until they start to become translucent.